Accessibility Tools
  • Icahn School of Medicine at Mount Sinai
  • NY Top Docs
  • Super Doctor
  • The New York Times
  • U.S. News
  • New York Post
  • New York Daily News
  • Newsday
  • The American Board of Orthopaedic Surgery
  • STATE TROOPER SURGEONS
  • How do I make an appointment?

    To make an appointment call during business hours and we will assist you in getting scheduled. You can also visit zocdoc.com/paulcagle to make a reservation online.

  • Where are your locations?
    • Monday 9AM-5PM at 425 West 59th Street 5th floor New York, NY
    • Wednesday 8AM-12PM at 300 Cadman Plaza Brooklyn, NY
    • Wednesday 1-5PM at 425 West 59th Street 5th floor New York, NY
    • Friday 9AM-1PM at 10 Union Square office 3K New York, NY
  • Please see the Office Visits Appointments and Directions section for details and maps.
  • What do I need to bring to my appointment?

    For your first consultation visit, a referral from your primary care physician may be needed. If you have any questions about this please contact us at before your appointment date. Additionally please bring: A current driver’s license or current valid ID

    • Health insurance information
    • A list of your current medication
    • Please bring any prior X-rays, MRIs, CT scans, prior Operative Reports or other relevant health information.
  • Will I need surgery?

    Each condition and injury is unique, and as such an individual treatment plan is created for every patient. Many patients are treated without surgery. Non-surgical options frequently involve physical therapy, injections, rest or an individual return to activity/sport plan.

  • What is minimally invasive surgery?

    Minimally invasive surgery in the shoulder and elbow utilizes cutting edge technology that allows many injuries to be treated with only small incisions, typically measuring less then 1cm (approximately 1/3 on an inch) each.

  • Will I have a scar?

    Although all surgeries require an incision in the skin, Dr. Cagle takes great pride in ensuring the incision(s) are as small as possible and are positioned carefully. Additionally, all incisions are repaired to ensure optimal cosmetic results.

  • When can I return to normal daily functions?

    Most patients are able to return to daily tasks almost immediately after surgery with restrictions for the operative arm. However, this may differ with the severity of the injury and the degree of surgery necessary.

  • Will I be able to drive after surgery?

    Cagle recommends a period of 2-6 weeks off from driving after a surgery. This depends on the type of surgery and the prescribed recovery plan. Please speak with Dr. Cagle about this once a treatment plan has been decided upon.

  • When will I be able to return to work?

    Many patients are able to return to work within a few days to a few weeks after surgery. Returning to full duty will depend on individual job requirements and the treatment plan decided upon.

  • When will I be able to return to exercise or sports?

    We have the privilege of taking care of recreational, collegiate and professional athletes and we strive to ensure everyone is able to return to their sport as quickly as possible.

  • How are patient health records managed?

    All patient health information is protected and kept absolutely confidential. Our team is well trained and will ensure the safety and security of your personal information.

  • What Types of Patients Dr. Cagle Treat?

    Cagle treats all patients with shoulder pain, elbow pain, sports injuries, shoulder arthritis, rotator cuff tears, labral tears, shoulder instability, shoulder or elbow fractures, dislocations, biceps tendon rupture, pectoralis rupture, shoulder separation, bursitis, impingement, tennis elbow, cubital tunnel syndrome, throwing injuries and weight lifting/fitness injuries.

  • How do I contact your office?

    You may contact Dr. Cagle at or at (212) 523-7584. Appointments can also be made through ZocDoc

Practice Locations

  • Monday : 8AM - 5PM

    425 West 59th Street
    5th Floor, New York, NY 10019

    Get Directions

  • Wednesday : 8pM - 12PM

    300 Cadman Plaza West
    18th Floor, Brooklyn, NY 11201

    Get Directions

  • Wednesday : 1pM - 5PM

    425 West 59th Street
    5th Floor, New York, NY 10019

    Get Directions

  • Friday : 9AM - 1PM

    10 Union Square East
    Office 3M, New York, NY 10003

    Get Directions